By Naomi Shulman, SlashFood: Vermonters are rightly proud of their signature export: rich, sweet, sticky, 100% maple syrup. Imitators have never quite been able to replicate it. But one purveyor of imitation syrup has a new product
on the shelves that's creating an extra-sticky situation in the Green
Mountains. (Full disclosure: I'm a Vermonter born and raised. That's
right, this is personal.)
Called Log Cabin
All Natural Syrup, the new product is indeed a kind of syrup, and it
may technically be "all natural" -- there are no artificial ingredients
or preservatives in the stuff. It's also in a new container -- one that
just so happens to look exactly like the jugs Vermont farmers have used
for decades. But that's where the resemblance ends.
Log Cabin All Natural Syrup is actually a blend of sugar, thickening
agents such as xanthan gum, caramel color, and a little bit of actual
maple flavor (we're talking 4 percent). Pure Vermont maple syrup,
meanwhile, is exactly what its name suggests, with a sole ingredient:
maple sap that's been boiled down to pancake-ready thickness.
A real Vermonter will never fall for Log Cabin's tomfoolery, but state
officials are worried about all you flatlanders out there. The "syrup"
blend is much, much cheaper than the real thing, after all -- and if you don't look closely, you might think you're buying something you're not. Vermont congressman Peter Welch
explained the concerns to the FDA: "While most Vermonters have a
discerning eye and palate for real maple syrup, the countless consumers
outside of our state who have come to expect quality from natural
Vermont products may be fooled by this misleading labeling."
Michelle Weese, a spokesperson for Pinnacle Foods, Log Cabin's parent company, told the Associated Press
that the company believes their new product "complies with all FDA
regulations." While this is a fairly weak endorsement, she may well be
right, considering that the FDA doesn't actually define the word
So, speaking on behalf of my home state: Caveat emptor! If what you want
is pure Vermont maple syrup (and trust me, that's what you want), make
sure the stuff you're buying has those words on the label.
Since 1995, "Where The Locals Eat" and LocalEats dining guides have featured locally owned restaurants across America. From the finest steakhouses and sushi bars, to classic burger joints and roadside barbecues, LocalEats recommends unique restaurants to suit every taste and price range.